Table of Contents
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch's Law on Thursday, ordering horse-drawn carriages off New York City streets by June 1, 2028, City Hall said.
- About 200 drivers, owners and stable hands work in the industry, and the city says the full plan to help them won't be released until April 2027.
- The Transport Workers Union filed a class-action suit in Manhattan federal court minutes after the signing, according to the New York Post.
- TWU International President John Samuelsen called the law "an unconstitutional abomination" that takes owners' medallions "without mandating or guaranteeing compensation."
The ink was barely dry.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed the bill ending New York City's horse-drawn carriage industry Thursday morning in the Blue Room at City Hall. Minutes later, the union that represents the drivers was in Manhattan federal court suing to stop it, the New York Post reported.
The law is called Romanch's Law. It orders every carriage off city streets by June 1, 2028, according to City Hall. It is named for Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist who died after a carriage accident in Central Park in June. Nobody serious wants to wave that loss away. A young man died, and his family deserves better than a talking point.
But look at how this was done.
"Our city has changed, and now it is time for our laws to change too," Mamdani said at the signing. He said he felt "a deep sense of both gratitude and obligation" toward the more than 200 New Yorkers in the business.
Gratitude is nice. A check is better.
City Hall says it will help those workers with medallion buybacks for owners, plus career services and job training for drivers and stable hands. The full plan? Due by April 2027. So the law is signed today, and the details on how the people losing their livelihoods get paid come months from now. The Post reported the mayor took no questions on the cost at the signing.
The union noticed. Transport Workers Union International President John Samuelsen didn't hold back.
"This bill is an unconstitutional abomination," Samuelsen said. "It strips horse-carriage owners of the city-issued medallions that they purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars, without mandating or guaranteeing compensation."
That's the heart of the lawsuit. The city sold those medallions. Families bought them. Now the city is shutting the business down and promising it will figure out the payout later.
You don't have to love horse carriages to see the problem. If City Hall can license your livelihood, take your money for the right to work, and then legislate it out of existence with a "trust us" on compensation, nobody holding a city permit should sleep easy.
And this isn't some right-wing grievance. The plaintiffs are a union. The TWU also represents tens of thousands of subway and bus workers. That's the coalition a progressive mayor is supposed to have locked down, and on Thursday it was filing papers against him.
Mamdani also wants a study of electric carriages and pedal-assist bikes as replacements in Central Park, City Hall said. Picture the postcard. A tourist on an e-bike, circling the park where the horses used to be.
Former Mayor Bill de Blasio stood beside Mamdani at the signing, the Post reported. He pushed for this ban for years and never got it done. Now it's law, and it's headed straight to a federal judge.
Some New York traditions last 150 years. Others last until the next mayor gets a pen.