Table of Contents
- Chicago Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch resigned Friday after about three months, writing that staying "would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations."
- Gabrysch, a former Fitch Ratings analyst, had publicly said only 56% of Mayor Brandon Johnson's moves to close an $882 million shortfall were structural, not the 76% he claimed.
- She is the city's third CFO in a year, and 12 aldermen led by Finance Chair Pat Dowell now want an outside firm to review three years of the city's financial statements.
- Johnson's office accused Gabrysch of being "largely absent" during budget prep and sent a $75 million payment question to the inspector general. She called it "an attempt to smear me."
- A special City Council meeting to vote on the review is set for Wednesday and would need 34 votes to be veto-proof.
Chicago just lost another money boss. That's three in a year. At some point you stop calling it turnover and start calling it a pattern.
Ashlee Gabrysch quit Friday after about three months as Mayor Brandon Johnson's chief financial officer. Her resignation letter didn't name names. It didn't need to.
"It has become apparent, however, that to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations," she wrote, according to CBS Chicago. "I therefore have concluded that I must step down from my role."
When a former Fitch Ratings analyst tells you she can't keep her name on your numbers, you should probably check the numbers.
Here's the fight, in plain English. Johnson rolled out a $17.6 billion budget and said 76% of his moves to wipe out an $882 million hole were structural. Real fixes. The kind that don't come back next year. Gabrysch went in front of the City Council and said no, it was more like 56%, because the borrowing to cover police misconduct settlements shouldn't count as a structural fix, the Chicago Sun-Times reported. Borrowing money to pay a bill isn't a structural fix. It's a credit card.
She was right, and she said it out loud, and that's apparently the one thing you can't do on the fifth floor of City Hall.
Gabrysch told the Sun-Times she was told what she could and couldn't say. "When I testified in front of City Council, I said a number of things I was told I could not say. They were not happy with me," she said. She said she never once met with the mayor one-on-one.
Johnson's people swung back hard. His office said she was "largely absent during critical periods of the City's budget preparation process" and flagged her decision to have the city treasurer send a $75 million payment to the pension funds, sending the matter to the inspector general. Gabrysch says the missed meetings were approved conferences, and that the payment went out after a veto-proof council majority approved it and 20-plus people knew about it.
"This effort by the administration to deflect from the serious issues at stake and attack those who attempt to hold them accountable is disappointing but not surprising," she said.
The council isn't buying the spin either. Finance Committee Chair Pat Dowell, who endorsed Johnson in 2023 and has since become one of his loudest critics, and 11 other aldermen filed an ordinance to hire an outside firm. The job: find out whether any "material or intentional misstatements of the city's financial condition" went out to investors, the council or the public in the last three years.
"In the wake of last week's resignation of the city's third CFO in a year, we find ourselves at a moment where every effort must be made to secure the public's confidence in our city's finances," Dowell said.
A special council meeting is set for Wednesday. Getting it done veto-proof takes 34 votes.
Johnson's office says it "welcomes any independent audit" and points to its annual reviews. Fine. Then there's nothing to sweat.
But look at what happened Monday. A proposed $500 million sewer bond got yanked from the Finance Committee agenda at the administration's request, the Sun-Times reported, which spared the acting CFO from testifying and maybe fielding a question or two about his predecessor.
Nothing to see here, folks. Just a half-billion-dollar bond pulled so nobody has to answer questions.
Gabrysch put the whole Chicago condition in one line. "Chicago has a history of making things look a lot better than they are," she said. "We come out with these billion-dollar deficits, and somehow, we make them disappear."
The magic trick only works if nobody checks the hat. This week, somebody's checking.