Skip to content

ONE DAY: Asked to Give Oct. 7 Victims a Day of Their Own, Mamdani Answers With 'Genocide'

Sorkin asked for one day for Oct. 7. Mamdani said 'genocide.'

Zohran Mamdani campaigns on a crowded Flushing sidewalk, with the words One Day and Mamdani Won't Give Oct. 7 Its Own Day.
Photo: InformedImages (CC BY 4.0)

Table of Contents

TheAmerican. Hit ListThe facts, fast.
  • At the New York Times DealBook Summit, Andrew Ross Sorkin asked NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani whether he would ever post one message about Oct. 7 alone and wait until Oct. 8 to criticize Israel.
  • Mamdani answered: "When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given... will be the relationship to Oct. 7."
  • Sorkin's question drew applause from the audience, Fox News reported.
  • Sorkin noted that about 53% of New York City hate crimes target Jews.
  • Mamdani's Oct. 7 anniversary statement accused Israel of a "devastating, ongoing genocide" in Gaza.

Andrew Ross Sorkin asked Zohran Mamdani for the smallest thing a mayor of New York can give, one day of mourning for murdered Jews with no Israel lecture stapled to it, and the mayor answered with the word "genocide."

It happened Wednesday on the New York Times' own stage. The DealBook Summit at Jazz at Lincoln Center, the friendliest room Mamdani will ever walk into, the one where he opened by greeting his "comrades," according to Fox News. The clip was still tearing across X on Thursday night.

Sorkin started with the mayor's own post on the third anniversary of Oct. 7. That statement condemned Hamas for killing more than 1,100 Israelis and taking 251 hostages, then turned to what it called Israel's "devastating, ongoing genocide" in Gaza, CNN reported at the time.

Sorkin read him the reaction. The head of the Reform Jewish movement said the statement made New Yorkers less safe. A rabbi who called himself a Mamdani fan asked, "Can we just have one day?"

Then Sorkin brought the number. "53%, I think, of hate crimes in New York City are against Jews," he said.

Mamdani said the post "doesn't cover the entirety of the day," pointed to a vigil he attended, and explained that his "politics is one that believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone."

Room for everyone. Sorkin had asked about one day.

Sorkin tried once more, slower, the way you would explain a parking rule to a tourist.

"My question is, would you ever think about sending out one tweet on Oct. 7, saying how terrible what happened on Oct. 7 was, and then waiting till Oct. 8 to say how terrible you think Israel has handled the situation?"

The audience applauded. A New York Times business crowd, clapping for the idea that dead Jews might get twenty-four hours.

Mamdani did not take the offer.

"When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it's asked about, will be the relationship to Oct. 7," he said. "My point being, this is a day that is not only a horrific war crime. It is also a day that has been used as a justification for all that followed it."

So the answer to "can the victims have one day" is that the victims' day is a justification. He wants it mourned in "totality." Hamas gets folded into the total. The 251 hostages get folded into the total. The more than 1,100 dead get a sentence before the word that the mayor actually came to say.

He did say he is "proud to be the mayor of the most Jewish city in the United States of America." He called the hate-crime numbers "unacceptable" and said "you have to root out antisemitism."

You do not root it out by refusing to give its victims a single day without an asterisk. Jewish New Yorkers are 10 to 12 percent of the city and the targets of more than half its hate crimes, by the mayor's own account on that stage. He looked at that number and still could not wait until Oct. 8.

"I have a politics of universality," Mamdani said.

The universal part is the word he will not let go of. He said it on the anniversary. He said it again on Sorkin's stage, with the applause still in the room.

Latest