Table of Contents
Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote all four chief federal judges in California on Saturday to warn them off signing search warrants for ballots until the state certifies its results. He also sent them a UC Berkeley guide on how to grade a warrant.
There is no warrant. Newsom said so in the second sentence: "I am not writing in connection with any warrant application currently pending in your courts, as I am unaware that there are any such matters at this time."
Why it matters. The Justice Department says it identified more than 20,000 likely noncitizens on California's voter rolls. A federal judge and then the 9th Circuit, in a 2-1 ruling Friday, refused its emergency bid to set their ballots aside. Newsom is now asking the judges who would sign any criminal warrant to give one "additional scrutiny" through Dec. 11, when California certifies.
What he told the judges. "California's strict chain of custody, documentation, and retention laws related to ballots and ballot materials ensure any evidence of alleged wrongdoing tied to ballots or ballot materials is preserved and appropriately supervised by a court, so there is no legitimate law enforcement reason to seize ballots," Newsom wrote. "Indeed, the only reason to do so would be to interfere in a State's lawful counting of ballots and certifying the results of the election."
He wrote that he has "grave concerns federal agents will seek search warrants" and that "the tactics and rhetoric federal officials are using strongly suggest that, having lost repeatedly in federal civil proceedings thus far, they will quickly pivot to the criminal forum."
The enclosure: "Questions for Assessing A Search Warrant for Election Materials," from UC Berkeley's Edley Center on Law & Democracy. His office billed it among "nonpartisan expert legal resources."
The prosecutor he named. Newsom accused Bill Essayli, first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, of having "explicitly threatened via social media posts criminal prosecution against elections officials." The post RedState quoted from Essayli reads: "Knowingly processing noncitizen ballots is a federal crime under 18 U.S.C. §§ 611 and 2. We will hold election officials accountable. No one is above the law."
Essayli answered on X Sunday. "This debate over noncitizens on California's voter rolls could be resolved in under a day if California simply used the same federal database it has relied on for 40 years to confirm Medi-Cal applicants' citizenship," he wrote, per the New York Post. He said 34 other states use it for voter checks. "What is California afraid of?"
The felony on the books. In September Newsom signed Assembly Bill 282, making the illegal seizure of ballots or election records before certification a felony punishable by up to three years in prison, the San Francisco Standard reported. "California WILL protect our elections," he posted Sept. 19.
The other side of the list. The DOJ's allegations have not established that 20,000 illegal votes were cast, the Post noted. In a sworn declaration, UCLA researchers said 8,880 of the 20,930 names did not match anyone on the state voter file; a Homeland Security official said a federal re-review of 200 names flagged by Los Angeles County found four people who might have a claim to citizenship, the Standard reported. On Friday another federal judge in California ordered DOJ and DHS to stop threatening election workers with prosecution.
Essayli has his own court problem. A federal judge ruled Tuesday that he is unlawfully serving as de facto U.S. attorney; the order is on hold while the government appeals, and Essayli says the Supreme Court will decide.
Newsom told the judges no warrant exists. Federal grand jury subpoenas already have three L.A. County election officials due in court the day after the election.