Skip to content

NOT SO FAST, GAVIN: 30 California DAs and Victims' Families Sue to Stop Newsom's Death Row Wipeout

548 killers, one pen. Prosecutors say Newsom skipped the law.

San Quentin State Prison on the edge of San Francisco Bay, with the words Not So Fast, Gavin and 30 DAs Sue to Stop Death Row Wipeout.
Photo: Frank Schulenburg (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Table of Contents

TheAmerican. Hit ListThe facts, fast.
  • District attorneys from 30 of California's 58 counties, joined by murder victims' families, asked the state Supreme Court to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute all 548 death sentences.
  • The petition, filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, says Newsom failed to give required notice to prosecutors and victims and skipped individualized review.
  • Under the state constitution, 382 of the cases involve inmates with more than one felony conviction and need the court's approval before any commutation.
  • The court has asked for briefs by Nov. 24, with Newsom's response due Dec. 4.

Gavin Newsom wanted to empty death row with one letter. Thirty district attorneys just told him to slow down.

Prosecutors from 30 of California's 58 counties, along with the families of people murdered by the men and women on death row, have asked the California Supreme Court to stop the governor's plan to commute every death sentence in the state, NBC News reported. The petition was filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation.

That's 548 people. 529 men and 19 women. All of them convicted, all of them sentenced to death by a jury, and all of them about to get life without parole because the governor decided "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with" California's values.

We covered the President's reaction when Newsom announced it. Now the people who actually try these cases are weighing in.

The foundation's announcement lays out the case in plain terms. Newsom, it says, failed "to provide legally required notice to district attorneys" and disregarded "the rights of victims and their families to be notified and heard." It calls the move an "abuse of executive clemency power" carried out "without conducting meaningful individualized reviews."

Anne Marie Schubert, the foundation's president and the former Sacramento County district attorney, put it this way in the filing. "Thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges set aside their personal views on the merits of the death penalty to render judgments based on the evidence and the law," she wrote. "Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process."

That's the whole fight right there. Twelve citizens in a jury box made a call. One politician in Sacramento wants to overrule hundreds of those juries at once.

There's also a hard legal wall. The California Constitution says the governor can't commute the sentence of anyone convicted of more than one felony without a recommendation from the state Supreme Court. By Newsom's own count, that covers 382 of the 548.

Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman, whose county accounts for more than 150 of the condemned, backed the challenge. His list of who's getting the break includes Chester Turner, the "Southside Slayer," convicted of 14 murders, and Michael Gargiulo, the "Hollywood Ripper."

Those are the people this is about. Not abstractions. Names, and victims with families who say nobody asked them.

The Washington Examiner reported that the DAs of Sacramento, Riverside, San Diego and Kern counties are also on board, and that Orange County's Todd Spitzer filed his own brief Monday challenging the 382 multi-felony cases. The court has asked for briefs by Nov. 24, and Newsom's office answers by Dec. 4.

Not every prosecutor is with them. Santa Clara County's Jeff Rosen backs the governor.

To be fair to the facts, nobody walks out of prison under Newsom's plan. Every one of them would serve life without parole. But Hochman points out that the Menendez brothers were once serving life without parole too, and look how that turned out.

California hasn't executed anyone since 2006. Newsom wants to make sure it never does again, and he'd like to do it without asking the victims' families first.

Thirty district attorneys think the law says otherwise. Now the court gets to decide.

Latest