Table of Contents
Abdul El-Sayed sat down with 60 Minutes two days before Michigan picks its next senator and said "the state of Israel did a genocide." Then he was asked whether Israel has a right to exist, and he couldn't get to the end of the answer without an "if."
Palestine got a one-word yes.
Here it is from CBS's own transcript, starting with a deflection El-Sayed has used before: "I don't ever get the question of, 'Does Palestine have the right to exist?'"
Correspondent Ross Douthat obliged. "Does Palestine have the right to exist?"
"Yes."
Then Israel. "S-- yes. If there is a shared understanding--"
"Wait. You said-- you said--" Douthat cut in.
"Let me just-- let me just-- let me just-- understand," El-Sayed said. He believes "in equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike," he said. If both sides choose "two states for two people" on equal terms, "I'm for it. If they decide that they want one state shared in a different way, I'm for that."
Read the back half again. One state "shared in a different way" is a map with no Jewish state on it, and El-Sayed said he's for that too. Palestine's right to exist came with no conditions. The Jewish state's waits on a vote nobody has scheduled.
The genocide line. Earlier in the same interview, Douthat asked what's wrong with America's relationship with Israel. El-Sayed gave a numbered list.
"Number one, we have been told that we are pursuing a two-state solution, only to aid, arm, and abet the very people who are trying to foreclose on the possibility of a second state. So it's incoherent on its own terms. Number two, I don't know about you, but I don't pay my taxes to buy another country a bomb or a tank. That's Israel. That's Egypt. That's Saudi Arabia. That's Pakistan. Three, the state of Israel did a genocide."
Item three. The worst charge you can level at a country, and a man who wants a Senate seat filed it third, after a complaint about his taxes. Israel rejects it. It's a smear. The Gaza war he's talking about followed Hamas's Oct. 7 attacks on Israel, which 60 Minutes put in its own narration. El-Sayed didn't mention them.
Rogers got it right. "His language is wrong. They use terms like genocide," Republican Mike Rogers told 60 Minutes. "I passionately defend Israel's right to defend itself and to exist as a Jewish state. That sets me at odds with my opponent right off the bat. He refuses to even acknowledge that Israel has the right to exist."
Rogers didn't need a paragraph. On the trail he made it even shorter: "So you've either got to pick your team. You want to represent Palestine, or you want to represent Michigan? I want to represent Michigan!"
Why it matters Tuesday. 60 Minutes opened the segment by saying control of the U.S. Senate may be decided in Michigan. The state has about 100,000 Jewish voters, by the show's count. The answer they got from the Democratic nominee two days out is on tape, here.
He's been here before. In July, CNN's Kasie Hunt asked El-Sayed three times whether Israel has a right to exist. He wouldn't say. "I'm not going to play this gotcha game about whether or not it has a right to exist," he told her, and called the question "actually quite secondary to whether it has a right to our tax dollars," according to Mediaite and Fox News.
In March, after a terrorist attack on a Michigan synagogue and preschool, El-Sayed said there is "never a justification for attacking innocent people or houses of worship." Then he added: "Hurt people hurt people." 60 Minutes said the line seemed to put blame on Israel. He later apologized.
Asked Sunday whether he's said enough to reassure Jewish voters, El-Sayed said: "Wherever our disagreements are when it comes to Israel, there are a lot more things that we agree on here. When it comes to standing up for Jewish-Americans, I will be right there."
Polls open Tuesday at 7 a.m. Mike Rogers says Israel has a right "to exist as a Jewish state." He didn't attach an "if."
Related: HE WON'T SAY NO: El-Sayed Calls Transgender Sports a "Manufactured" Issue : Then Pivots to Phones [WATCH]; Pelosi Won't Name El-Sayed on Podcast. Next Day She Tags Him.