Table of Contents
I used to think a Senate candidate could at least answer the easiest question in American life: should a biological male be in a girls' locker room or on a girls' sports team. Then I watched Abdul El-Sayed talk to 60 Minutes.
Ross Douthat asked the Michigan Democratic nominee, flat, about "transgender kids on sports teams" and places "where rights are in conflict." El-Sayed did not draw a line. He did not say no. He said he did not know that was "actually true," and that "we manufacture these social issues" — because, he told Ross, you have a phone in your pocket with "all the world's information," so the idea you can keep your kid from something "disagreeable" at school is "so profoundly outdated." The free flow of information is "a beautiful thing." Coach your kid. The internet "is a real thing."
WATCH: Mike Rogers posts El-Sayed 60 Minutes clip
That is the answer. Not a locker-room policy. A TED Talk about iPhones.
Rogers and Travis named the dodge. Republican Mike Rogers — Trump-endorsed, running against El-Sayed for the Michigan Senate seat that may decide the chamber — posted the clip and framed it for what parents hear when a Democrat will not say no: ".@AbdulElSayed says it's ok for MEN to be in girl's locker rooms. Why? 'Well because they are going to find out about it on the internet anyway' Completely unacceptable." The post passed two million views overnight. Clay Travis quote-tweeted it and did not soft-pedal: "Democrats unwillingness to simply say men pretending to be women shouldn't be allowed in women's spaces is truly insane. Listen to this answer. It's complete gibberish."
Clay Travis on El-Sayed
Rogers and Travis put the locker-room words on the table. El-Sayed's own mouth, on the tape we watched, never said them. That is not a defense. That is the problem. Asked about girls' sports and conflicting rights, the man who wants a U.S. Senate seat called the conflict manufactured and changed the subject to Samsung versus iPhone.
I have been wrong before about how far a candidate will go to avoid a yes-or-no. I still did not expect the phone bit.
We already hit him on Israel. Same interview family, same week — he told 60 Minutes "the state of Israel did a genocide," then hung an "if" on Israel's right to exist while Palestine got a one-word yes. This piece is the other tape: the one where he will not protect girls' spaces either. Two dodges. One nominee. Election Eve in Michigan.
Mike Rogers did not need a seminar. He called it unacceptable and let the clip run. Clay Travis called it gibberish. The voters still have to decide whether "manufactured social issue" is good enough for their daughters' locker rooms — or whether a grown man who answers that question with a speech about his pocket has already told them everything they need.
Related: Pelosi Won't Name El-Sayed on Podcast. Next Day She Tags Him.