Skip to content

Boasberg Hands Noncitizen-Voter List to Immigrant-Rights Group

DOJ warned the list could tip off subjects of pending investigations. The judge gave it a 5 p.m. deadline. By Friday night, the plaintiffs had it.

Stylized punk/zine Featured illustration of Chief U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg over a redacted list, stamped "20,000 Names" and "5 P.M. Deadline."
Illustration by TheAmerican. Base: Chief U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg at a National Archives naturalization ceremony, December 2024 (NARA photo by Susana Raab / public domain). File photo.

Table of Contents

Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg on Friday ordered the Justice Department to turn over its list of 20,000 alleged noncitizens registered to vote in California to the immigrant-rights group suing over it.

The deadline was 5 p.m. ET the same day.

So the list the government built to check California's rolls went to the group suing over that check, four days before the midterms.

The receipts

The minute order, issued Oct. 30 in Washington, D.C.: "By 5:00 p.m. today, the Government shall disclose to Plaintiffs the 20,000-person list at issue."

The plaintiff is the Los Angeles-based Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, which sued in September over the administration's effort to screen state voter rolls for noncitizens. The group says it needs the list to establish standing — its legal right to bring the case.

DOJ fought it. In a stay motion, the department said handing over the list — names, birthdates and addresses — could interfere with "pending" investigations "by informing individuals who are subjects or witnesses."

DOJ let the 5 p.m. deadline pass and said it would appeal. Then it withdrew the stay motion and appeared to comply, handing the list over Friday evening, according to Democracy Docket.

Boasberg's order bars the coalition from disclosing names on the list "to anyone" or telling any person "that his or her name is on the list."

The response

"It's a list of voter McCarthyism," said Chad Dunn, the coalition's attorney. "If you're a voter in California you have to wonder, are you on this list?"

The coalition argues federal database-matching risks wrongly flagging naturalized citizens. NBC News reported that election officials have noted many registrations flagged by DOJ appear to be U.S. citizens.

DOJ's standing line: "As a general rule, the Department of Justice does not confirm, deny, or release information about pending investigations, both to protect the integrity of any investigation and the rights of any accused."

Background

DOJ says the Department of Homeland Security built the list by matching California's voter roll against federal immigration records. DOJ has also sued California and Los Angeles County officials to keep ballots from the 20,000 from being counted.

Boasberg's order came in one of two cases he is hearing on DOJ's efforts to separate ballots and potentially delay election certification, NBC reported.

Election Day is Tuesday. The government's file on 20,000 California registrants spent the weekend with the people suing to stop the government from using it.

Latest