Table of Contents
I'll defend almost any hard ad. I grew up in a house where the TV stayed on through the late news every October and my dad graded the attack spots like a high school football coach grades game film, tough but fair, missed tackle, nice hit, and I came out of that living room believing that politics is a contact sport and the people who complain about contact are usually the ones losing. So when Vivek Ramaswamy's campaign said it would put $4 million behind a closing ad in the Ohio governor's race, my first instinct was to pull up a chair.
Then I saw who was in it.
The ad featured Amy Acton's mother, Donna Arthur, calling her daughter a liar. As the Washington Post's Karen Tumulty reported, Arthur and her daughter have not had contact since 1978, "when Arthur's second husband, Cledith Arthur, was indicted and charged with raping his 12-year-old stepdaughter." The stepdaughter was Amy Acton. She and her brother were removed from the home.
There is a real argument against Amy Acton, and this site has made it, on the merits, and would make it again. That argument got buried the week this ad went up, and the man who buried it was our own nominee, in a state that, per the Post, has not elected a Democratic governor in 20 years. That's the lesson, and it holds whether Ramaswamy wins Tuesday or not: one bad call in the fourth quarter can cost you more than the money you spent making it.
The scoreboard moved first. On Oct. 23 the Cook Political Report shifted the race from Toss Up to Lean Democrat. "It's an inescapable law of politics: Money can only propel a campaign so far when its candidate's flaws act as an anchor," Cook wrote. Cook's Jessica Taylor said the decision to run the ad "confirmed that the race is slipping away from him — and perhaps creating some collateral damage for fellow Republicans on the way." Sabato's Crystal Ball had made the same move the day before, WLWT reported, and Cook flagged the risk spreading to Sen. Jon Husted's race against Sherrod Brown. The campaign's answer was to keep calling Acton a "serial fabulist."
Then our own people spoke up. Mike DeWine, the Republican governor of Ohio and nobody's idea of a squish on this race, called the ad "deeply disturbing" and urged Ramaswamy to take it down. Later in the week he went further: "deeply, deeply troubling." Husted, who has his own name on the same ballot, said he would not have run it. Casey Putsch, who ran against Ramaswamy in the primary, said he'd vote for Acton. When the sitting Republican governor, the Republican senator and the guy you beat in May all walk off the field at the same time, it isn't the referees.
And then the money stopped. The campaign pledged $4 million. It pulled the ad after spending only a quarter of it, about $1 million, according to the Associated Press citing AdImpact. Ramaswamy told reporters in Vandalia that the ad "ran to completion, and we've put up four other ads." Maybe so. A campaign that plans a four-million-dollar buy and stops at one usually has a reason, and he didn't offer it.
Now, the vice president. JD Vance told the critics to "stop whining about an advertisement and go win the race." President Trump said, "Vivek was treated very unfairly." I get the instinct. I've said some version of stop whining to every losing locker room I've ever been in, including a few where I was the one whining, and I'd rather have a party that fights than a party that frets. But a coach who tells his team to stop whining after a turnover still has to look at the film, and the film here is not complicated. The newest New York Times/Siena poll of likely Ohio voters has Acton at 49 and Ramaswamy at 43, and Brown at 49 against Husted's 44 in the Senate race the ad was never supposed to touch.
The fair counterweight. Ohio polls have flattered Democrats before. Sabato's Crystal Ball itself noted that pre-election polling in Ohio has had a tendency over the past decade to show Democrats doing better than the final result, and even two strategists close to Acton told the Post they still consider it a toss-up, noting GOP voters in Ohio tend to come home late. Ramaswamy can still win this. I hope he does. And if he does, I'd bet a tank of gas the reason will be some speech he's been giving lately and not anything the Arthur ad accomplished.
He found the line, eventually. In Lorain County on Saturday, Ramaswamy told the crowd, "It's communism versus common sense." You can argue about whether that's the right frame for Amy Acton. It's a frame, an argument about where Ohio goes next, the kind of thing a voter in Elyria can hold up against his own grocery bill and decide. A woman calling her estranged daughter a liar on a 30-second spot gives that voter nothing to weigh except how it made him feel, and we already know how it made the governor feel.
Money wasn't the problem. Nationally, Republicans have outspent Democrats on ads every week since Labor Day, $305 million to $256 million in the week of Oct. 23 to 29 alone, per AdImpact. Ramaswamy vastly outspent Acton too. The final Emerson national poll still had Democrats up 52 to 42 on the generic ballot. In a year like that, the margin for error is the width of a church pew, and you don't spend any of it on a 48-year-old family wound.
I love Ohio, the plants and the parishes and the Friday night lights, and I love that our side finally learned to hit back. Hitting back means aiming. The voters in Lorain County deserved the argument about communism and common sense from the first week of October. What they got for a stretch in the middle was a family's worst day, paid for by our side.
Stop whining, sure. Look at the film first.
Related: ICE-KKK DEM WINS OHIO: Acton Beats Vivek After Comparing Agents to the Klan; Amy Acton's ICE-Ku Klux Klan Clip Resurfaces Days Before Ohio Picks a Governor