Table of Contents
The New York Times spent Sunday night selling a blue wave. Its own final battleground poll found the voters who made up their minds last are breaking red.
"There are still some undecided voters, and voters who decided only in the last month favored Republicans by a nine-point margin," the Times reported, as quoted by The Daily Signal.
Nine points, among the people who were still shopping in October.
The toplines, straight. Times/Siena surveyed 5,708 likely voters in seven Senate battlegrounds from Oct. 23 to Nov. 1. Democrats lead in six of them, and Iowa is a coin flip, according to the Siena Research Institute's release:
Michigan: Abdul El-Sayed 53, Mike Rogers 42.
Texas: James Talarico 50, Ken Paxton 43.
Maine: Troy Jackson 51, Sen. Susan Collins 45.
Ohio: Sherrod Brown 49, Sen. Jon Husted 44.
Kansas: Adam Hamilton 49, Sen. Roger Marshall 44.
Alaska: Mary Peltola 48, Sen. Dan Sullivan 46.
Iowa: Josh Turek 48, Ashley Hinson 47. Siena calls it "virtually tied."
Michigan's numbers also came in before Sunday's endorsement of Rogers by Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens, El-Sayed's old primary rival.
The fine print. Even the Times flagged where its poll is weakest. "Blue-collar white workers have proved particularly hard to reach in polls, and polling error has previously been among the highest in that demographic," the paper wrote. That's the backbone of the Trump coalition, and it's the group the Times admits is hardest to poll.
Siena's own director, Don Levy, wouldn't call it. "With so many races within the poll's total margin of error, a Senate majority for either party remains possible," he said. "Now, it's time for all votes to be cast and the counts to speak louder than the polls."
Even CNN's numbers guy. Harry Enten went on CNN Sunday and called the Times/Siena release "a polling earthquake," the Daily Beast reported. Then he added the part the blue-wave crowd skipped.
Polling "has tended, at least in the Trump-won states, to underestimate Republicans during the Trump era by an order of 4.1 points in the close Senate races," Enten said.
If Alaska, Iowa, Texas and Kansas go red, he said, "all of a sudden Republicans get to 50 Senate seats," with the vice president breaking ties. "So Republicans are still very much in the game."
A 4.1-point polling miss in Trump country, by Enten's count, and a nine-point late break in the Times' own data. The people who decided last already picked a side.
The rest is turnout, and it's happening now.