Skip to content

'A MOOT ARGUMENT': Incoming Democrat Adam Hamawy Won't Say Israel Has a Right to Exist as a Jewish State

Six tries on Iran, too. He says it's "not a binary yes or no."

The U.S. Capitol dome against a blue sky, with the words A Moot Argument and Incoming Dem Dodges Israel's Right to Exist.
Photo: Architect of the Capitol

Table of Contents

TheAmerican. Hit ListThe facts, fast.
  • New Jersey Rep.-elect Adam Hamawy, a Democrat headed to Congress in January, was asked on NJ PBS whether Israel has a right to exist as a Jewish state.
  • He answered "It currently exists," called the question "a moot argument," and said every country has that right only alongside equal rights for its people.
  • Asked for a sixth time across two interviews whether Iran is a U.S. adversary, he said "it's not a binary yes or no" and blamed America for "provoking" the war.
  • He called President Trump's talk about Iran "a genocidal statement," and in an earlier CNN interview said he wants to cut all military aid to Israel, Iron Dome included.

It's the easiest question in American politics. Does Israel have a right to exist as a Jewish state? Yes. One word. Most members of Congress can say it in their sleep.

Adam Hamawy couldn't say it on camera.

The New Jersey Democrat won his House seat on Nov. 3 and takes office in January. He sat down with Rob Nelson of NJ PBS News after an earlier CNN interview had already blown up nationally. Nelson gave him every chance to clean it up.

"Do you believe that Israel has a right to exist as a Jewish state?" Nelson asked.

"It currently exists," Hamawy said. "It's the same question that everyone keeps asking over and over again. I think every country has a right to exist, but it should be providing equal rights to its people and providing civil liberties, human rights." Then he called the whole thing "a moot argument."

Nelson didn't let it go. He compared the dodge to a Republican who, asked whether Joe Biden legitimately won in 2020, will only say Biden was sworn in. "The question is, should they exist?" Nelson said.

Hamawy's answer was to ask why everybody keeps asking him about Israel.

Here's why, Congressman. Because the "equal rights" condition is the tell. Israel is a democracy where Arab citizens vote, serve in the Knesset and sit on its courts. Nobody puts that condition on France. Nobody puts it on Japan. The only country that has to pass a test before an American congressman will admit it should exist is the Jewish one.

Then came Iran. By Nelson's count, CNN's Pamela Brown had asked Hamawy five times on Tuesday whether Iran is an adversary of the United States. Nelson asked a sixth.

"We don't want to make adversaries," Hamawy said. "And it's not a binary yes or no." He said the United States is "provoking and creating the situation that we are in right now, where we're in a war."

The regime that chants "death to America," that funds Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis, whose Revolutionary Guards bragged Sunday about firing drones at a base in Bahrain that hosts U.S. forces, and the incoming congressman can't call it an adversary. Six tries.

When Nelson asked whether he sees a moral equivalence between the two countries, Hamawy pointed at the president. "We have President Trump saying that we should nuke Iran. That is a genocidal statement," he said, and argued that both sides' rhetoric "should be discontinued." Breitbart and others flagged the answer as exactly what it sounded like.

In the CNN interview, according to published transcripts, he said the U.S. was "pushed into this war by Israel" and called it "illegal and immoral." He wants to cut off all military aid to Israel. That includes Iron Dome, the system that knocks rockets out of the sky over Israeli kindergartens.

Roz Rothstein, the co-founder and CEO of StandWithUs, said he was refusing to acknowledge a "moral reality."

She's right. And Hamawy won't be some lone voice in the back row. He's part of an incoming class of Democrats who flinch at the word Israel and can't find the word adversary for Tehran. Ro Khanna is already pitching "zero weapons to Israel" as he eyes 2028. The socialists are plotting to purge Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries as "ultra-Zionists."

Hamawy says he wants to focus on New Jersey. Fine. The Jewish families of New Jersey would like to know where their next congressman stands on the one Jewish state on earth. They got their answer. It's "moot."

Latest