Skip to content

ASKED THREE TIMES: Fetterman's Socialist Challenger Won't Say Whether He's Pro-Hamas

Ahmed Moor called it "bad faith," then said Americans are "done with Israel."

The Pennsylvania State Capitol dome in Harrisburg, with the words Asked 3 Times and Fetterman Foe Won't Say If He's Pro-Hamas.
Photo: Acroterion (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Table of Contents

TheAmerican. Hit ListThe facts, fast.
  • Ahmed Moor, a Democratic Socialists of America-backed writer who plans to challenge Sen. John Fetterman in Pennsylvania, went on Fox News' "The Story" on Monday.
  • Host Martha MacCallum asked him repeatedly whether he is "pro-Hamas," after Fetterman had described him as "very pro-Hamas."
  • Moor never said yes or no. He called it "a bad-faith question" and said he would not engage with it.
  • Instead he called for "comprehensive sanctions on Israel" and said "Americans on left and right are done with Israel."

It is the easiest question in American politics. Are you on the side of the terrorists who butchered families on Oct. 7?

The answer is one word. Ahmed Moor couldn't find it.

Moor, a Democratic Socialists of America-backed writer who plans to take on Sen. John Fetterman in Pennsylvania, sat down with Martha MacCallum on Fox News' "The Story" on Monday. She opened with Fetterman's own description of him.

"So, John Fetterman, who you may run against, says that you are very pro-Hamas," MacCallum said. "Is he correct?"

"Look, John Fetterman's story's over," Moor said. "The main story today is the Democratic mandate."

She didn't let him wander off. "I'm asking you a question. Are you very pro-Hamas?"

What followed, per the transcript Mediaite published, was a tour of everything except the answer. He said he wants "equal rights in Palestine and Israel." He said he opposes what he called "Israeli apartheid." Then he got to what he actually wanted to say.

"I'd like to see comprehensive sanctions on Israel," Moor said, comparing it to the 1986 sanctions on apartheid South Africa.

He had nothing to say against Hamas. He had a whole plan for sanctioning the Jewish state.

MacCallum tried again. She pointed out that Hamas has been a disaster for the people of Gaza, with poverty that was already at 35% when the terror group took over and is now in the 60s. "So my question once again, if you would just answer it: are you pro-Hamas leadership in Gaza?"

Moor pivoted to blaming Israel for, well, all of it. "The Israelis have too much influence in our foreign policy," he said. He accused Benjamin Netanyahu and President Trump of taking America to war in Iran.

"I've now asked you three times and you won't answer my question," MacCallum said. "You won't answer the question about whether or not you support Hamas, which attacked Israel on October 7th, killed many people. It was a vicious attack."

"It's a bad-faith question," Moor shot back. "I'm not going to engage with that."

Then the closer. "Americans on left and right are done with Israel," he said. "We're done with the tail wagging the dog."

Stop on that phrase for a second. "Tail wagging the dog" is the old smear that a small, scheming ally secretly runs American foreign policy. Pair it with "too much influence" and you know exactly what tune he's humming.

Fetterman has spent three years as the rare Democrat who stands with Israel without flinching, and he has taken plenty of arrows from his own party for it. And now the socialist left wants to replace him with a man who can't bring himself to say he's against Hamas on national television.

This is where the energy in the Democratic Party is right now. You saw it with the DSA vote to push AOC into 2028. You saw it with the incoming congressman who called Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state "a moot argument." Now it's a Senate hopeful in Pennsylvania.

It is not "bad faith" to ask a man running for the United States Senate where he stands on a terrorist group that murdered Americans. It is the job.

And Moor's dodge was its own answer. If the question were really unfair, the word "no" was right there, free of charge. He walked past it three times.

Pennsylvania voters will remember that. For years the left has insisted "anti-Zionism" is just policy talk. On Monday night, it sounded like a lot more than that.

Latest