Skip to content

BAD COMPANY: NBC News Chief Chairs the Gala for a Press Group That Calls Israel's War a 'Genocide'

A watchdog says CPJ's Gaza list still counts terror-tied men.

30 Rockefeller Plaza, home of NBC News, seen from Fifth Avenue, with the words Bad Company and NBC News Chief Chairs CPJ Gala.
Photo: D. Benjamin Miller (CC0)

Table of Contents

TheAmerican. Hit ListThe facts, fast.
  • NBCUniversal News Group Chairman Cesar Conde is chairing the Committee to Protect Journalists' International Press Freedom Awards dinner Thursday in New York, the group says.
  • CPJ's website says Israel is silencing the press in what "human rights groups and UN experts agree is a genocide."
  • After a review, CPJ removed 19 terrorists and 3 other fake journalists from its Gaza list but reinstated 4 others, the Washington Free Beacon reported. HonestReporting says 102 of the 191 names left still have terror ties.
  • Pro-Israel watchdogs CAMERA and HonestReporting are urging media backers to stop lending their names to the group.

Thursday night in New York, the people who run your nightly news will put on black tie and toast a press group that calls Israel's war a genocide. NBC's top news executive is chairing the party.

The Committee to Protect Journalists holds its 36th International Press Freedom Awards dinner Thursday in New York City. The event will be chaired by Cesar Conde, chairman of the NBCUniversal News Group, according to CPJ. Lulu Garcia-Navarro of The New York Times is the emcee.

That is a choice. Here's what NBC's boss is lending his name to.

CPJ's own website says that "by silencing the press, Israel is silencing those who document and bear witness to what human rights groups and UN experts agree is a genocide," the Washington Free Beacon reported.

Then there's the list. For more than two years, CPJ has kept a tally of "journalists" killed in the war in Gaza. The Free Beacon published a series of reports this year showing that list included confirmed terrorists and Hamas fighters. Some had posed with weapons. Some were honored in Hamas "martyr videos" after they died.

CPJ did a review. When the results came out in late September, it took 19 terrorists and 3 other fake journalists off the list, then put 4 others back on who had been removed for terrorism against Israel, the Free Beacon reported. That left 191 names.

HonestReporting, the Israel-based media watchdog, went through the new list. It says 102 of those 191 still have "connections to terrorist groups."

Read that again. More than half.

The list still includes Anas al-Sharif. The Israel Defense Forces released evidence it says shows he was an active Hamas fighter, including a photo of him hugging Oct. 7 mastermind Yahya Sinwar. Times columnist Lydia Polgreen, the vice chair of CPJ's board, has called him "a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist" who was "assassinated."

In June, the board also voted 17-1 that outlets "affiliated with militant groups" can count as real news organizations, as long as their people aren't "engaging in combat or inciting violence in a manner likely to have imminent effect." The one no vote came from Fox News's representative on the board.

So, to sum up. Terror-linked outlets can count as press. Terror-linked men can count as slain reporters. And Israel gets the genocide label.

Pro-Israel groups are saying what the networks won't.

"By counting terrorists as journalists they do the exact opposite," HonestReporting told the Free Beacon. "Until CPJ corrects the record and changes its methodology, no self-respecting journalist or reputable publication should have anything to do with them."

CAMERA, the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis, asked the obvious question. "When scandals emerge, how can journalists so intimately tied to an advocacy group with flawed verification standards be expected to cover that group critically, as their profession demands?"

CAMERA also said CPJ's habit of naming journalists, then quietly dropping names when Hamas or Islamic Jihad claims them, "plays right into Hamas's strategy of wielding the press as a weapon in its war against the Jewish state."

NBC and the Times didn't answer. The Free Beacon said it had asked both for comment over the last six months about their support for CPJ and got nothing back. Every supporter it contacted for this story either didn't respond or declined to comment.

That silence says plenty.

Nobody is against protecting real reporters. Journalists get jailed, beaten and killed around the world, and somebody should stand up for them. That's exactly why this matters. When a press group pads its count with terrorists, it insults every real reporter who died doing the job.

NBC asks you to trust its coverage of Israel every night. On Thursday, its news chief will chair the big night for a group that has already picked a side.

You can decide what that tells you.

Latest