Skip to content

MOSCOW ROOTS THE BLUE WAVE: Russian Papers Pin the Wipeout on Trump

Kommersant says Trump "did not live up to his own expectations." The Kremlin's own paper calls his strategy "a failure" and predicts investigations. Moscow's papers and America's legacy press filed the same midterm autopsy on the same morning.

TheAmerican. type-only still: Moscow papers blame Trump for the blue wave; red stamp quote Did not live up to expectations — Kommersant.
Type-only. Moscow papers pin the blue wave on Trump. No faces. TheAmerican. WORLD desk.

Table of Contents

At a ballgame, when the visiting section starts cheering every mistake your coach makes, you learn something about who they would rather see coaching. Wednesday morning the visiting section was Moscow, and the cheering came printed.

Newsweek's Brendan Cole did the reading on Nov. 4, and it is worth a slow look. Newsweek notes that the Kremlin keeps Russian newspapers on a tight leash. So when those papers all wake up on the same morning with the same verdict on an American election, nobody should mistake it for a burst of independent analysis.

Kommersant went first. The business daily ran a headline Newsweek translated as "Donald Trump did not live up to his own expectations," and pinned Democratic gains in the House and Senate on the cost of living and a gas-price spike from the Iran war. Newsweek's own words: Kommersant did this "like U.S. newspapers." Sit with that. A paper in Vladimir Putin's capital and the cable panels in Midtown filed the same autopsy on the same day, and Moscow's version blames a war on Tehran, the regime that sold Russia the drones it fires at Ukrainian apartment blocks. Funny how that works.

Then the tabloid. Komsomolskaya Pravda rounded up analysts. Political scientist Ivan Pyatibratov said "Trump's rapprochement with Russia will be hampered" and that Democrats could push for more Ukraine aid and tougher sanctions. "However, the president has veto power," he added. Andrey Manoylo of Moscow State University called a result giving Democrats at least 54 Senate seats, plus losses in red states, "a serious loss of public confidence in Trump." Manoylo also speculated that Trump "may try to cover up his defeat with a military adventure." That is a Russian professor's guess, printed by a Russian tabloid, and it gets no more weight here than that.

The Kremlin's own paper wrote the Democrats a to-do list. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, the government's official mouthpiece, ran an op-ed by Evgeny Shestakov headlined "Apocalypse Today." It called the midterms "an unspoken vote of confidence in the head of the White House himself" and said "the strategy chosen by Trump turned out to be a failure." Shestakov then predicted, per Newsweek, that Trump now faces investigations over corruption and enrichment and renewed scrutiny of Epstein ties. Read that list again and then read the first press release from any incoming Democrat committee chairman in January. I would bet a tank of gas they match.

I'll confess something. Election night, I wanted somebody to blame, and for about an hour I sounded like an anonymous House staffer on background. Then I read Moscow's papers and got a lot less interested in sounding like anybody on their side of the ocean.

The officials smiled for the cameras. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Trump "will continue his mandate" and added, "We sincerely hope that he will continue his peacekeeping efforts," with possible talks with China at APEC in the background. Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said Moscow's position on Ukraine would "not depend on fluctuations in the political barometer in other countries."

So that is the full picture. The diplomats say nothing changes. The newspapers, which say what they are allowed to say, spent the day dancing on what they called a failure and handing House Democrats a subpoena menu. Rooting from the cheap seats costs nothing, and the Kremlin's papers know it.

Here is the part of the blue-wave autopsy the Acela press will skip. When an adversary's state-supervised press and your own legacy press grade the President identically, on the same morning, using the same talking points, one of them is not doing journalism, and both of them are telling you what they hope comes next.

The President still has the veto pen. Pyatibratov said so himself. Moscow can cheer whoever it likes from the visiting section. Our country has the home field, and two years on the clock.

Related: TEHRAN TOASTS THE DEMS: Mullahs 'Endorse' Blue Wave, Threaten 'Nightmare'; SEAT AT THE TABLE: Trump Envoys, After Meeting Putin, Say They See a Path to Bring Europe Into Ukraine Talks

Latest