Table of Contents
- HUD Secretary Scott Turner finalized a rule requiring proof of U.S. citizenship or eligible immigration status from every applicant and tenant in public housing and Section 8, regardless of age.
- The rule ends the option to simply "not contend" status and makes partial aid to "mixed-status" households temporary while every family member is verified.
- A HUD and DHS audit found nearly 200,000 HUD-assisted tenants with incomplete or unknown eligibility, while HUD housing serves only a quarter of eligible families in need.
- The rule takes effect Dec. 14. Turner, who pitched it Sunday on Fox's "Sunday Night in America," summed it up when HUD announced it: "Promises made, promises kept."
If you're waiting on a housing list in America, you are about to move up. The government is finally going to check who is ahead of you.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner has finalized a rule that requires every applicant and every tenant in public housing and Section 8 to prove they are a U.S. citizen or an eligible noncitizen. Every one. The final rule applies "regardless of age," and it takes effect Dec. 14.
Turner took the case to Fox's "Sunday Night in America" with Trey Gowdy on Sunday. His department had already put it bluntly.
"It's unacceptable that America's homeless veterans, disabled, elderly, and victims of domestic violence languish on waitlists while illegals and ineligibles scam our system," Turner said when HUD announced the rule. "American taxpayers will no longer foot the bill. Promises made, promises kept."
The numbers back him up. A joint HUD and DHS audit of every HUD-assisted household found nearly 200,000 tenants with incomplete or unknown eligibility verification. Meanwhile, HUD says its housing reaches only a quarter of the eligible households who need it. That's the scam in one sentence. Three out of four struggling American families get nothing, and the system didn't bother checking the paperwork on the people already inside.
Here's how the loophole worked. Under the old rules, a family member could simply decline to claim eligible status. The household then got "prorated" assistance covering only the eligible members, and it could go on that way forever. In plain English, an illegal alien could live in taxpayer-funded housing indefinitely as long as somebody else in the unit qualified. Tenants 62 and older were also exempt from showing evidence.
The new rule kills all of that. The "not contend" option is gone. The age exemption is gone. Prorated aid for mixed-status families becomes a temporary condition while everyone in the home gets verified, as the Federal Register notice spells out.
Housing agencies will check status through DHS's SAVE system, according to a breakdown from the law firm Ballard Spahr. Citizens sign a declaration, give a Social Security number and sign a consent form. Mixed-status households already in the system get 90 days after the rule takes effect to turn in their evidence, which puts the deadline in mid-March. Everybody else proves it at their next annual or interim review. Landlords in the voucher program are not on the hook for checking anyone.
This is the boring, unglamorous part of keeping a campaign promise, and it matters more than most speeches. Trump signed an executive order called "Ending Taxpayer Subsidization of Open Borders." Turner has been grinding it into policy for months. HUD signed a data-sharing agreement with DHS. It changed FHA rules so FHA-backed loans go to American citizens, and HUD says loans to non-permanent residents fell to nearly zero. It told local housing authorities to verify tenants or risk their funding. It opened a hotline to report illegal aliens and crime in HUD housing.
The housing advocates are furious, of course. They warn that families will have to choose between living together and keeping their aid. But the rule doesn't break up anybody's home. It asks the people living on the public dime to show that they're legally allowed to be here. Every American who has ever applied for a mortgage, a passport or a job has done the same thing.
Want a picture of who wins here? Think of the veteran sleeping in his truck while the waitlist barely moves. Think of the grandmother who has been number 400 on that list for three years. This rule is for them.