Table of Contents
Two Dans. One Senate seat. A gap you can count on your fingers if you use both hands and a calculator.
Fox’s Matt Finn put it on the air Wednesday in round numbers: about 600 votes between the leaders. A guy they call Decoy Dan on roughly 3,500. Gerald Heikes — drywall man, fourth name on the card — on about 4,800, telling Fox a Midwest operative recruited him. Sen. Dan Sullivan versus Democrat Mary Peltola. Virtually tied. Uncalled.
I don’t trust round numbers when a seat is this thin. So I opened the state’s own sheet.
Alaska Division of Elections. Unofficial. 400 of 401 precincts.
Mary Peltola: 102,962.
Dan S. Sullivan — incumbent, registered Republican, the middle initial that was supposed to keep the peace: 102,325.
Gap: 637.
Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. — no party, retired teacher, ballot twin: 3,600.
Heikes: 4,846.
Write-ins: 695. Total in the race: 214,428.
Do the math cold. The decoy alone has more votes than the margin that could flip a U.S. Senate seat.
WATCH: Fox’s Matt Finn — ~600 votes, “Decoy Dan,” and Alaska’s uncalled Senate race
NBC still has Peltola ahead. Race still uncalled.
CBS has both camps warning the Lower 48: Peltola says it won’t be hours or days — it will be weeks. Sullivan tells supporters they’re probably looking at long weeks.
Alaska doesn’t even start ranked-choice tabulation until the last ballots are counted, fifteen days after Election Day, if nobody clears 50 percent on first preferences.
Nobody is clearing 50.
Democrats already took the Senate. Alaska is the leftover knife fight.
Open a sample ballot and the absurdity stops being abstract.
Sullivan, Dan S. Republican. Incumbent.
Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr. Blank party line. Ghost with paperwork.
Mary Peltola. Gerald Heikes.
Four names. Two of them answer to Dan Sullivan.
The Alaska Supreme Court kept the second Sullivan on. The Division of Elections was ordered to leave him. The ballot printed both.
The New York Times and Fox already ran the recruitment story — voter-roll hunts for men named Dan Sullivan, an operative under aliases, DOJ letters, FBI knocks in Petersburg where the other Dan’s house went dark. That’s prior reporting. I’m not re-litigating the carnival.
I’m staring at the arithmetic after the tents folded.
Six hundred-ish on Fox. Six hundred thirty-seven on the PDF.
Three thousand six hundred for the almost-senator name.
Four thousand eight hundred for the drywall contractor who says he got recruited.
Stack those two side characters and you’ve got a pile bigger than the cage Sullivan and Peltola are fighting in.
Some people will call that democracy. Some will call it ranked-choice complexity. On the Alaska sheet it’s a photocopy with wet ink.
Fox named him Decoy Dan on national air. The state’s PDF names him Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr. Same animal. Different collar.
I’m not inventing a quote from the teacher. He denied being a plant earlier. He’s not answering phones in the AP’s Petersburg piece. His yard once held a League of Women Voters sign: Stand Up for Democracy.
Democracy stood up. Next to another Dan Sullivan. It took 3,600 first-choice votes while the real fight stayed inside a 637-vote box.
If that doesn’t make your teeth itch, you’re watching elections like a screensaver.
Refresh the PDF until the last precinct coughs.
Watch whether ranked-choice turns Decoy Dan’s leftovers into somebody else’s second-choice air.
Keep Finn’s clip: six hundred, three thousand five hundred, Heikes at forty-eight hundred saying a Midwest operative found him.
Then look at the official tallies again.
637. 3,600. 4,846.
Names matter. Alaska printed the receipt.