Table of Contents
Two minutes after Michigan's Democratic Party chair threw Rep. Haley Stevens out of the party on Sunday, conservative lawyer Will Chamberlain summed up the whole thing in one sentence.
"Democrats are angrier at Haley Stevens for endorsing Mike Rogers than they were at Graham Platner for having raped his ex-girlfriend," Chamberlain, senior counsel at the Article III Project, wrote on X. It had more than 11,000 likes by Monday morning.
Platner, the Maine oysterman who won the Democratic Senate primary there in June, was accused, and he denies it. In July, Jenny Racicot, a woman who dated him on and off for two years, told Politico he came into her home uninvited in late 2021 while drunk and forced himself on her as she told him to stop. Platner called it "categorically untrue." A second ex-girlfriend, Lyndsey Fifield, told The Washington Post he removed condoms without her consent. His campaign called that "categorically false and politically motivated."
What Stevens got. Stevens, who lost the Michigan Senate primary to Abdul El-Sayed by a hair in August, posted a video Sunday endorsing Republican Mike Rogers. Party chair Curtis Hertel answered on X just over an hour later: "Congresswoman Stevens is not a current member of the Michigan Democratic Party, nor will she be in the future." That post has topped 60,000 likes.
Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer, who backed Stevens in the primary, called it "a despicable betrayal." Rep. Jared Huffman of California went with "Pathetic, petty, selfish, unhinged," according to Axios. Her former chief of staff said "many members of our team have resigned."
What Platner got. Democrats did push him out. That part of the record is real. The Maine Democratic Party asked him to step aside the day the Politico story ran, saying it "stands with women and survivors," Maine Morning Star reported. Schumer and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand said the party's Senate campaign arm "will not invest in the Maine Senate race if Platner remains on the ballot," per Reuters. Rep. Ro Khanna pulled his endorsement.
Look at what they asked for, though. A candidate accused of rape got a request to withdraw. He said he was "taking the time to reflect on the best path forward," then announced two days later he was out and filed the paperwork July 10. When he went, he told supporters, "We're not doing it because of the allegations," according to NBC News.
His withdrawal letter signed off: "F*ck ICE. Free Palestine. Up the Hearts." Maine Democrats replaced him at a convention later in July, AP reported.
Chamberlain was measuring anger. The clock is easier to read: about an hour from endorsement to expulsion for Stevens, four days from the Politico story to withdrawal papers for Platner, and Platner left on his own paperwork.
In her video, Stevens said El-Sayed had told her she was no longer welcome in his campaign. "He's right," she said, according to Axios. "I don't belong in Abdul's campaign." Michigan votes Tuesday.