Table of Contents
Biscuit was a beagle-hound mix from Goochland County, Virginia. She was by every account a good dog. She has been dead for about five years. And according to a certificate bearing Gov. Abigail Spanberger's signature and the Lesser Seal of the Commonwealth, she is also a convicted felon whose right to vote and serve on a jury has now been restored.
The paperwork showed up in her owner's mailbox. It names "Biscuit Rigsby" and says she had been "convicted and sentenced for crime(s)" and that the Executive had "completed review of the particulars of the individual's case." Somebody in Richmond reviewed the particulars. The particulars had four legs.
The owner, who asked not to be named to dodge the political blowback, confirmed the document was real to Fox News Digital and gave the line of the cycle: "To my knowledge, she was never convicted of a felony, nor did she ever show any interest in voting."
Then he brought it to his delegate.
Garrett wants an audit. Del. Tom Garrett, R-Buckingham, a former congressman who practices law in Fluvanna County, posted the certificate on X and is calling for an investigation. "Biscuit was a dog. Biscuit has been dead for five years. Yet an official document bearing the governor's signature says the executive reviewed the particulars of Biscuit's criminal case and determined her rights should be restored," Garrett said. "Virginians deserve an explanation for how that is possible."
He wants an immediate independent audit of Spanberger's restorations, the underlying record that flagged "Biscuit Rigsby" as a felon, and a count of how many certificates went to dead, nonexistent or duplicate people, per Fox. In his video he asked the obvious next question: "At what point does rank incompetence and malfeasance become criminal conduct?"
WATCH
And he kept it out of the partisan ditch, which makes it harder to wave off. "This should not be partisan," Garrett told Virginia Scope. "Whatever your position on restoration of rights, Virginians should be able to expect that the Governor knows whether the individual whose rights she is restoring is, at a minimum, number one, alive, and number two, actually a person."
That is a low bar. Alive. Human. Pick one, even.
What Spanberger's office says. The governor's people say the dog story is a mix-up of names, not of species. "Of course we did not restore the rights of a dog," a spokesperson said. "We cannot disclose this individual's information, but we can tell you that it is associated with a person with a date of birth and Social Security number." Spanberger told CBS 6 the state cross-checks Virginia State Police and Department of Corrections records, and that a restoration does not register anyone to vote. A person whose rights come back still has to go register, and then decide to cast a ballot.
Fine. So take the governor at her word. Then a real human being's restored rights went out on a certificate made out to a dead dog, and mailed to the dog's house. As far as the owner knows, the only Biscuit in that house was the dog they lost about five years ago, and she never had a brush with the law. Nobody in the governor's office has explained how that name ended up on a certificate mailed to that address. That is the part Garrett wants audited.
The governor's own explanation is the best ad for the audit. "We are working with clunky subpar databases, frankly," Spanberger told CBS 6.
Betty No Last Name, meet Biscuit. This is the second embarrassment in weeks. Earlier, a certificate went out to "Betty No Last Name" in Chesapeake. Spanberger blamed a September spreadsheet glitch: "the last name was put in the spreadsheet as the middle name, mail merge, no last name was listed."
Mail merge. That is the machinery. In July the administration said the Secretary of the Commonwealth would be proactively finding Virginians who had lost their rights, confirming they were eligible and restoring them, according to Garrett. In August Spanberger announced she had hit 100,000 restorations since taking office in January. That's a hundred thousand certificates run through clunky subpar databases and a mail merge, and at least one of them went to a dog.
Tomorrow, the training wheels come off. Virginians vote Tuesday on Question 3, which would make restoration of voting rights automatic on release from incarceration. Richmond Democrats backed it and Spanberger pushed it. Under the current system a person in the governor's office is at least supposed to review each case, and the certificate says that review happened. Biscuit got through anyway.
Question 3 would drop the case-by-case step altogether. Voters can decide if that's the fix.
Biscuit's owner told Garrett she was "a good dog and is greatly missed." She never asked for her rights back. Virginia sent them anyway, seal and all.